The University of Texas at Austin
Mission to Mars

Problem Generation

In our model, Problem Generation plays a critical role in defining the area of research and developing the degree of interest needed to motivate students during their teacher-led inquiry and learning activities.Essentially, we break the problem generation phase down into three components:

Problem Generation Activities Affordances Materials
Problem Posing Pose problems individually Generation of Problems in context Mission to Mars video
Problem Definition Define problems in small groups (articulate and refine) Chance to refine problems with group input Activity instructions, curriculum guide
Categorization Groups categorize problems Development of understanding of interrelationships between problems Curriculum guide
* From Hickey, Petrosino, Pellegrino, Goldman, Bransford, Sherwood and CTGV (1994)

How to Do It?

We have found that each class does the Problem Generation activity slightly differently but here we offer what seems to be a simple description of the activity and encourage other teachers to experiment with this methodology and see what works best for them.

First Class Period: the students view the Misison to Mars video, write down any problems/challenges that come to mind and wait for everyone to finish. They draw a line under their last problem and watch the video once again. After the second viewing, activity is repeated. We generally find that upon a second viewing, the children's amount of problems increase substantially in both number and quality sine they have a much better idea of the task.The class breaks up into smaller groups and begins to better define the problems as well as start the categorization process.

Second Class Period: Each group sorts their problems into self-specified categories. Then the class categorizes all of the individual sets of problems into a master set of categories. This will eventually led to the cooperative teams or expert groups in the next step of THE BASIC MODEL.

Third Class: The kids now decide what group they want to belong to based on the categories generated. These students then collect the questions that were put into their category and create a prioritized set of problems for their category (group). This will be the foundation of the questions that will guide their research over the next 4-6 weeks.

A list of typical questions that middle school children have asked in the past during the problem generation phase of the Mission to Mars unit can be viewed by clicking here. While your own students may pose other problems, we believe this list gives a good representation of what to expect.

UT Directory | UT Offices A-Z | Campus & Parking Maps | UT Site Map | Calendars | UT Direct