Title of lesson: Probing for Genes
Source/Author(s): Restriction digest, Southern blotting, and hybridization protocols modified from Biology 4106: Molecular Genetics Laboratory Manual, Baylor University, Spring 1997, compiled by Dr. Christopher Kearney. Gel electrophoresis protocol modified from Access Excellence Activities Exchange, online at http://www.accessexcellence.org/AE/AEPC/geneconn/castgel/
Target Audience: High school Biology I (honors) or Biology II
Lesson plan:
I. Performance or learner outcomes
The student will be able to:
Use the scientific method to perform an experiment, practice safe laboratory techniques, cut DNA with restriction enzymes, perform agarose gel electrophoresis, perform Southern blotting, perform DNA hybridization record an accurate laboratory observations, and write a reflective lab report that interprets the findings of their experiment.
II. Overview: This investigation involves the Human Genome Project’s goal of learning about other organisms to better understand ourselves, and will last for two and a half weeks. The students will identify commonalities between mice, pigs, and humans, then select a gene they might share. They will then perform an experiment in which they will probe pre-extracted mouse, pig, and human DNA for this human gene (the human DNA serves as a control). Techniques include using restriction enzymes to cut DNA, agarose gel electrophoresis, and Southern blotting. Students will also keep a lab journal reflecting their daily participation in the experiment, and they will write a lab report documenting and interpreting their work. This lab investigation requires much out-of-class preparation by the teacher to fit the experiment into a 50-minute bell schedule. If it is possible for the students to set aside one day as an in-shool “field trip”, they will be able to complete more of the steps themselves.
III. Resources, materials and supplies needed:
Equipment: Computers for internet access, waterbath, micropipettors (p20), gel electrophoresis kits (agarose minigel) that include chambers, lids, pouring trays, combs, and power supply, refrigerator, freezer, microwave, hybridization oven, vacuum drying oven, shaker, and camera (digital or Polaroid).
Supplies: Spiral for lab journal, non-powdered latex gloves, microcentrifuge tubes, flasks, 50 ml Falcon tubes, pipet tips (p20), tip disposal jar, paper towels, hotpads, pint-size Ziploc freezer bags, lab masking tape, Whatman 3MM paper, nitrocellulose membrane, plastic wrap, glass trays, sponges, glass pipette, glass plate (about 8 x 10), paperweight (not too heavy), hybridization bags, foil, blunt-ended forceps, biohazard bags, squeeze bottles for ddi H2O.
Reagents: Pre extracted mouse, pig, and human DNA, double deionized (ddi) H2O, restriction enzyme, restriction buffer, agarose (0.8%), 10X TAE, 20X SSC, loading dye (for agarose gels), 0.25M HCl solution, denaturation solution, neutralization solution, prehybridization solution, neutralization solution, hybridization solution, nonradioactive DNA probe (custom ordered), wash buffer, Blocking buffer, Anti-DIG-alkaline phosphate, Detection buffer, x-phosphate solution, NBT buffer, color substrate solution.
**Note** Many of these supplies are costly, especially the larger equipment. Austin Community College’s BioTechEd program offers an outreach program to loan supplies to high schools free of charge. These supplies include micropipetters and electrophoresis equipment. They might also be able to contact other labs to make other equipment available for use, as well as offer teacher support in ordering supplies. For more information, contact Peggy Maher at 512-223-3285.
IV. Supplementary materials, handouts: Lab protocol worksheet, images, webliographer (http://webliographer.com/humangenome)
V. Standards
Texas Essential Knowledge and Skills: 112.43.1 A and B; 112.43.2 A, B and C; 112.43.3 A
National Science Education Standards: Understandings about science and technology (content standard B), identify questions and concepts that guide scientific investigations, design and conduct scientific investigations, use technology and math to improve investigations and communications, communicate and defend scientific argument.
Engagement
|
Student behaviors / activities |
Teacher behaviors / activities |
|
Think about the body plans of mice, pigs, and humans, and identify similarities between the three organisms. Listen attentively to teacher’s description of the experiment and lab journal. |
Ask students what mice, pigs, and humans have in common and discuss their responses as a class. The teacher will then introduce the experiment, informing the students that they will select a human gene to look for in mouse and pig DNA. The teacher will also discuss the lab journal, stating that it should include, 1.notes over concepts and procedures, 2.a record of all protocols, also indicating which steps the student participated in, and 3.observations. Pages should be dated and numbered. A handout with these requirement can be given to students if desired. |
.
Exploration
|
Student behaviors / activities |
Teacher behaviors / activities |
|
Part 1: Selecting a gene Students will look at the chromosome map found on the webliographer page, and as a class they will choose a human genetic disease that might also be found in pigs and mice based on the similarities identified by the class. They will find out what protein is affected, then look up the sequence of the gene that codes for that protein (see webliographer for link to GenBank `99). This will be the gene they will probe for. Students will participate in a discussion to decide on a hypothesis as a class, which they will record in their lab journals. At this point, the students will divide into groups at the teacher’s discretion. Two will be assigned mouse DNA, two pig DNA, and two human DNA (control). Part 2: Restriction digest Students will answer any questions asked by the teacher, and they will take notes in their lab notebook. Students should follow along in the lab protocol while the teacher is reviewing, recording any special notes in their lab journals. Students should practice using the micropipettes with water before beginning the experiment. In groups, the students should perform steps as directed by the lab protocol, and record all procedures and observations in their lab journals. Part 3: Gel Electrophoresis In groups, the students will cast an agarose gel, load DNA, and perform electrophoresis according to protocol. The student should also answer questions asked by the teacher and record notes, procedures, and observations in their lab journals. Part 4: Southern Blotting In groups, the students will assemble a Southern blot according to protocol. The student should also answer questions asked by the teacher and record notes, procedures, and observations in their lab journals. Part 5: Hybridization In groups, the student will perform DNA hybridization according to the protocol. Since the teacher will also perform some steps due to time constraints, students should review these steps along with the teacher to grasp their purpose. During any free time, the group should meet and work on the lab report. The student should also answer questions asked by the teacher and record notes, procedures, and observations in their lab journals. |
Part 1: Selecting a gene The teacher will offer advice to the class in selecting a gene to probe for. Good criteria might include a protein with only one form, as well as a short gene sequence. The teacher will also order nonradioactive probes for this gene from a company specializing in this. At this point the teacher will ask the class if they know what a hypothesis is, making sure they understand that it is the prediction they will be testing in their experiment. The teacher will guide the class with questions to agree on a justified hypothesis about whether or not the mouse and pig share the human gene, and why or why not. The teacher will break the class into groups and assign them the type of DNA to probe. It is important that the students realize the human trial is the control in the experiment.
Before beginning, the teacher will briefly review lab safety that had
already been discussed at the beginning of the year, as well as the
importance of careful handling of materials and accurate measurement during
this experiment. Emphasize that
students should wear latex gloves at all times. The teacher will give an introduction to restriction enzymes (by lecture and asking questions to draw upon students prior knowledge and reasoning skills) that includes the following information: 1. Restriction endonucleases are bacterial enzymes that cut DNA at certain short sequences that they recognize. 2. Why do bacteria have these enzymes? –to destroy foreign DNA from something that might harm the bacteria. The teacher will then review protocol handed out to students, and also give a demonstration on using the micropipettor. Ask the students to pick them up and find the two stops when pushing down the plunger: the first is the point to which you push when drawing up liquid, and the second is the point to which you push to eject liquid out of the tip. Instruct each student to practice putting tips on the pipetter and practice measuring with water. During the activity, the teacher will circulate around the room, monitoring each group’s activities and offering assistance when needed. Part 3: Gel Electrophoresis As in the previous part of the experiment, the teacher will give an interactive introduction to gel electrophoresis. The following information should be conveyed to the students: 1. An agarose gel is a solid form in which the agararose particles are scattered with spaces between them. When surrounded by electrophoresis buffer (containing electrolytes), it will conduct a current through it when a power source is applies. 2. DNA has a negative charge. What would happen if DNA was placed in a gel and current applied?—the negative charge would be attracted to the electric current, and the DNA would move down the gel with the current. 3. In the last lab, the DNA was cut into pieces—are all these pieces the same size? Will the large pieces and small pieces travel at the same speed down the gel? --The larger pieces have a harder time moving through the spaces between the agarose particles, so they move more slowly. Small pieces move fast, and the DNA will separate according to size. Before class: The teacher will need to prepare TAE and agarose (see protocol). The agarose solution will need to be kept at 65˚C in a waterbath. During first day, the teacher will review the protocol with the students, giving a demonstration of how they should set up the pouring tray. The teacher will also warn students 1. not to burn themselves while pouring the gels, and 2. to use caution when handling the fragile gels, as they will tear easily. During the activity, the teacher will assist students in pouring their gels, making sure each apparatus is set up correctly before pouring. After checking for proper storage, the teacher will also transport gels to the refrigerator to be stored in for the next day. The teacher will also assist students to prepare the DNA for loading, making sure all are wearing gloves while handling the loading dye. The teacher will warn students of its toxicity (formamide is a terratogen, which mutates the sex cells). During the second day, the teacher will have the gel boxes assembled at each group’s station in order to save time. The teacher will also have the waterbath ready at 95˚C so the students can denature the samples they prepared earlier, as well as have ice available for after the denaturing. The teacher will review the loading protocol with the students, and also emphasize caution when using the power supply. Assist students in loading gels, instructing them to eject the pipet tip slowly and carefully so that all of the sample goes into the well. Before turning on the power supply, check each groups wells to ensure proper loading. Also check the running voltage and wattage to make sure it is at the correct settings. The teacher will likely have to turn off and store the gels after class since they will have to run longer than the class period. Part 4: Southern Blotting As in the previous part of the experiment, the teacher will give an interactive introduction to Southern Blotting, using the graphic image as a resource. The following information should be conveyed to the students: 1. Southern blotting transfers the DNA from the gel to a nitrocellulose membrane, where the DNA can be fixed and analyzed. 2. The transfer happens by capillary action of the buffer moving up through the layers, carrying the DNA to the membrane. 3. How do we get the DNA to stick to the membrane?--first denature it (make it single stranded before blotting), then bake it in a vacuum oven. While the gels are running on the day before the previous day, the teacher will review the protocol and supplies needed for Southern blotting, giving a demonstration of what the students will do. Warn the students to use caution when handling the gel and them membrane: they both tear easily. Also the membrane should be handled with clean forceps, not gloves. On the day of the activity, the teacher will circulate throughout the room to check each group’s setup and answer any questions the students may have. Part 5: Hybridization As in the previous part of the experiment, the teacher will give an
interactive introduction to DNA Hybridization that should include the
following information. 1. DNA hybridization is the joining of
two comlementary strands, in this case the DNA from the gel and the single
stranded probe. 2. The probe is designed so that it is
complementary to a section of the gene we’re looking for. 3. How do you see the probe?—It has receptors that bind to
antibodies. After soaking the
membrane in the probe that will bind to the gene, it is soaked in the
antibodies that will bind to the probe.
These antibodies can then be detected by adding a coloring agent. This section of the lab is extensive and will take three days to complete. The teacher will need to complete steps that the student will not have time to do (see protocol). The teacher will also need to prepare solutions for use by the students. During the lab, the teacher should circulate throughout the room to check each group’s progress and answer any questions the students may have. Also advise the students to work on their lab reports during any lag time (while waiting for the membrane to finish soaking). |
Explanation
|
Student behaviors / activities |
Teacher behaviors / activities |
|
Students will answer questions about that day’s activity, follow along with the lab protocol, and record notes and steps in the lab journal. |
Before each section of the lab exploration, the teacher will review concepts, protocols, and safety measures with the students. |
Elaboration
|
Student behaviors / activities |
Teacher behaviors / activities |
|
Each lab group will briefly share their results with the class (3-5 minutes) and state whether they are able to reject or accept their hypothesis. They will then participate in a discussion over how this activity fits into the Human Genome Project. They should think about the number of genes shared with organisms like the roundworm and the chimpanzee, and think about what this means in terms of evolution. |
After group presentation of results, the teacher will state that 50% of our DNA is the same as a roundworm, and 99% is the same as a chimpanzee. To start a discussion, ask what the students think this means in terms of evolution. How might knowing the gene sequences of other animals help the human race? Does it change our view of the human species and its place in the world? |
Evaluation
|
Student behaviors / activities |
Teacher behaviors / activities |
|
The students will keep a chronological lab journal, recording any notes given for the day, the steps in the experiment conducted that day, a record of what the student does, and any significant observations. Each group will also submit a lab report, composed of 5 sections: 1. introduction, 2. hypothesis with predictions, 3. methods, 4. results, 5. conclusion. The first three sections will be submitted as a rough draft, and the final paper will include all five sections. Students will also present their findings to the class in a brief presentation near the end of the nine weeks. |
The teacher will collect lab journals once per week during the lab investigation and comment on what the student is doing correctly and what areas need improvement. The teacher will hold a meeting with each group to give feedback after reviewing the rough draft. During this meeting, the results and conclusions will be discussed to make sure the students are heading in the right direction with their final papers. The teacher will evaluate the papers based on how well they interpret their results in relation to the hypothesis, how accurately they reflect the methods, and how well they documented the results of the experiment with descriptions and pictures. |
RESTRICTION DIGEST PROTOCOL
Restriction endonucleases (or enzymes) recognize short DNA sequences and cleave double stranded DNA at specific sites within or next to the recognition sequences. A restriction digest has many different applications in molecular biology, but for our purposes, we must cut the whole DNA into smaller fragments so that they will migrate down an agarose gel during electrophoresis in the next section.
DNA Sample
10X restriction enzyme buffer (should be available with enzyme)
Restriction enzyme (EcoRI is listed, but if a recognition sequence is present within the gene you’re probing for, you’ll want to pick a different one with a different recognition sequence)
Double-deionized (ddi H2O)
Waterbath
Access to a freezer
The concentration of DNA may vary, and the volume to be added will be designated by your teacher. The amount by weight should be about 4 μg of DNA.
GEL ELECTROPHORESIS PROTOCOL
Background
In the lab introduction, you learned that electrophoresis (a term which
literally means "to carry with electricity") is a technique for
separating and analyzing mixtures of charged molecules. Clearly this separation
wouldn't work very well if the molecules were just sprinkled on the surface of
the gel box fluid! Instead, the mixture to be separated is "loaded"
into slots or "wells" of a slab of jelly-like material called agarose.
Agarose is a very pure form of agar, which is actually made
from a kind of seaweed.
To prepare or "cast" an agarose gel, agarose powder is mixed with buffer, heated, and poured into a casting or gel tray containing a comb. When the gel has cooled and solidified, the entire casting tray is lowered into the gel box and covered with buffer, which allows the electricity to flow and prevents changes in pH. The comb is removed, creating empty wells. Then, a micropipettor is used to place a small amount -- usually just a few microliters -- of the mixture to be separated into each well.
In order to track where the "invisible" DNA runs on a gel, we add two dyes to the DNA sample. One dye runs slightly faster and farther than DNA; the second dye runs slower and not as far as the DNA.
Materials per team
Power supply
buffer [1X TAE]
glass beaker, 50 ml, for agarose
gel box with gel tray
loading dye
beaker, 500 ml, for buffer
P-20 micropipette & tips
container for waste (tips)
agarose, [0.8%], melted & kept hot in a 65 degree C bath
or incubator.
Waterbath
ice
Solution
preparation (by teacher):
1X TAE: This buffer usually comes in 10X concentration, so dilute 1
part buffer to 9 parts ddi H2O for use with electrophoresis.
Agarose: Mix
one-two batches of 0.8% agarose in 1X TAE buffer (not water!). For example, 400 mL of 0.8 % agarose
would be enough for 15-20 teams, each using 20-25 mL. To make this, mix 3.2 g
of agarose power in 400 mL of 1X TAE buffer. Microwave the solution at 30 second intervals until the
agarose completely dissolves when swirled. Place the beaker in a 65˚C waterbath to keep in liquid state
until students are ready to pour their gels.
Part 1: Casting a Gel
1. Loosen the screws at the ends of a casting tray, if
necessary, to raise the "gates" at each end; then, tighten the screws
(not too tight) until there is enough tension to hold the gates in place. If
the gel tray does not have gates, apply tape across the ends of the tray so
that it will hold liquid. Insert a
comb in the end slots of the empty tray. The teeth of the
comb should not touch the bottom of the tray! See diagram.

Loading the Gel


REMEMBER - keep the pipet plunger depressed to the SECOND STOP until the pipet tip is out of the gel box or you'll draw your sample back into the tip!
Electrophoresis of the DNA
NOTE: Due to the short class periods, your teacher will likely have to stop the power and remove the gels from the boxes for you. Make sure your baggie is labeled and next to your gel box so that you get the correct gel back the next day.
SOUTHERN BLOTTING PROTOCOL
In order to probe DNA, it has to be fixed onto a membrane first (we are using a nitrocellulose membrane). DNA cannot be probed on an agarose gel. The southern blot takes advantage of capillary action to transfer the DNA molecules from the gel to the nitrocellulose membrane. Remember that nitrocellulose must be handled with care because it is rather brittle.

Materials: Shaker platform, ddi H2O, denaturation solution, neutralization solution, glass baking dish, 20X SSC buffer, nitrocellulose membrane, sponges, paper towels, Whatman 3MM paper, saran wrap, glass pipette, glass plate, paperweight, blunt-edged forceps, scissors, pencil, vacuum oven.
Procedure:
Preparing gel (done by teacher):
1.
Rinse the gel in ddi H2O and place in a
clean tray containing ~ 10 gel volumes worth of 0.25M HCl. Shake slowly on a platform shaker for
10 minutes at room temperature.
2.
2. Add ~ 10
gel volumes worth of denaturation solution and shake for 30 minutes at room
temperature.
3. Pour off the denaturation solution and rinse the gel with distilled water. Add ~ 10 gel volumes worth of neutralization solution and shake for 30 minutes.
The HCl changes the chemistry of the DNA, allowing the DNA strands to be denatured by the denaturation solution (they “unzip” down the middle and become single-stranded). Only single stranded nucleic acids bind to the membrane used in the Southern blot. In addition, the DNA must be single stranded to be able to base-pair (hybridize) with the probe. The neutralization solution brings the pH to <9 so that the DNA will bind to the membrane used in the next part of the experiment.
Southern blot:
HYBRIDIZATION PROTOCOL
In the last section, you performed a Southern blot to transfer the DNA from the agarose gel to a nitrocellulose membrane for probe analysis. This membrane will be pretreated with a prehybridization solution to make the DNA receptive to the probe. The probe is then added (in a hybridization solution) to the membrane and incubated in the hybridization oven. This oven regulates the temperature as well as shakes the membrane to ensure thorough coverage by the solution. If the gene we’re looking for is present on the membrane, the labeled DNA probe (which is complementary to a region of the gene), will bind to the gene. The membrane will then be washed in an antibody solution that binds to the probe. This antibody can be detected with an agent that will change color where the probe is locate.
Day 1:
Day 2:
Probe detection:
Day 3: